Lucky Me

You are invited to rate and comment on the 39 films of Doris Day.

How do you rate "Lucky Me"?

Poor
2
3%
Average
20
34%
Good
23
40%
Excellent
13
22%
 
Total votes: 58

User avatar
Johnny
Honorary Member
Posts: 3641
Joined: 10 Oct 2007, 16:02
Location: Toronto, Canada

Re: Lucky Me

Unread post by Johnny »

Hi Bryan and Peter,

I watched Lucky Me near St. Patrick's Day and I too have always enjoyed the enthusiastic opening scene with Doris skipping down the street. Doris radiates joy. The strong supporting cast is really funny. Bryan, I think as you do, Lucky Me takes on a deeper meaning since Doris has left in body but not in spirit.

Peter, I agree with you regarding Robert Cummings as a leading man. Doris' strong personality needs a stronger leading man that can match her bright wit and confidence. Some of strongest leading men that were a good match for Doris were Danny Thomas, Howard Keel, Steve Cochran, James Cagney, James Stewart, John Raitt, Clark Gable, Rock Hudson, James Garner, Stephen Boyd, Rod Taylor and Brian Keith.

Some thoughts on Doris' leading men:

The leading men that worked out well for Doris and the films were Jack Carson, Dennis Morgan, Gordon Mac Rae, Gene Nelson, Frank Sinatra, ,Jack Lemmon, David Niven and Peter Graves.

The leading men in Doris Day films that were miscast and were not good matches for Doris were Kirk Douglas, Ray Bolger, Ronald Reagan, Robert Cummings, Louis Jordan, Richard Widmark, Rex Harrison, Cary Grant (who should have been cast in the lead in Midnight Lace -- he would have been terrific as the male lead in Please Don't Eat The Daises ), Richard Harris and Robert Morse.

Gregory Peck would have been a good choice as the lead in Young Man With A Horn as well as The Winning Team.

Errol Flynn would have been an interesting choice as the lead in April In Paris. He would have made a good romantic match for Doris.

I would have liked to see Montgomery Clift in the Louis Jordan role in Julie. He had the intensity as well as the subtlety to give a strong performance. Paul Newman would have been effective.

Jack Lemmon would have been a better choice in the Richard Widmark role in the Tunnel of Love. Glenn Ford was the original choice.

William Holden or Glenn Ford would have had a better chemistry with Doris than Richard Harris in Caprice.

Jack Lemmon would have been great in the Robert Morse role in Where Were You When The Lights Went Out.

Although some of these scripts were admittedly weak, the films may have been stronger with better leading men casting who had better chemistry with Doris..
Johnny

User avatar
Johnny
Honorary Member
Posts: 3641
Joined: 10 Oct 2007, 16:02
Location: Toronto, Canada

Re: Lucky Me

Unread post by Johnny »

This is some information on Lucky Me is from the TCM website:


"When Warner Brothers pushed Doris to start work on Lucky Me, she was not well and kept putting the project off. She was also disappointed with the script and found it to be below the standard of her usual productions. Robert Cummings, Phil Silvers, Nancy Walker, Eddie Got Jr. we're all talented funny people she said, "but I knew by now that no amount of talent could overcome an inferior script, especially if it is a comedy".

Day seriously considered taking a suspension from the studio rather than make Lucky Me. It was a common practice for actors to who didn't want to appear in a film they believed was inferior. A close friend of Day's talked her out of abandoning the picture commitment. Day agreed and made the decision to give Lucky Me her very best effort, no matter what.


Although it is impossible to tell from just watching Lucky Me was not an easy film for Day to make. "Whereas I had always been able to get into the part with effortless vitality", she said, " now it was all I could do to get myself up to the performing level". She tried to rest as much as possible and not exhaust hetself in an effort to keep the panic attacks at bay." I attempted to do this by resting in my dressing room as much as I could , avoiding all interviews, and closing the set to visitors." She said, " Some days if the shooting schedule was too long, I asked the director to shorten it. Judy Garland was on the lot at the same time making A Star is Born(1954); she was being difficult and erratic about her hours and the press lumped us together as the Warner Bros. prima donnas. I tried not to let that bother me. My primary obligation was to keep myself well enough to finish the picture. Nothing else really mattered"

It appears this fundamental belief, "a deal is a deal" remained true in the late sixties when she made Do Not Disturb, Caprice and Where Were You When The Lights Went Out.


As another Doris Day Forum member wrote, some of the Doris Day film scripts were inferior but Doris' performances never were.
Johnny

User avatar
Johnny
Honorary Member
Posts: 3641
Joined: 10 Oct 2007, 16:02
Location: Toronto, Canada

Re: Lucky Me

Unread post by Johnny »

In David Kaufman's book on Doris Day, there is an interesting observation from actor Robert Cummings who worked opposite Doris Day on the film Lucky Me.

According to Robert Cummings, Day chose him as her leading man. When I first met Doris, I didn't know who she was, he recalled. I was doing a tense dramatic scene in "Dial M for Murder", I looked up past the camera and hot lights to see a fuzzy figure in a white sharkskin slack suit, perched atop an eight foot stepladder . Day continued to observe Cumming at work on the Hitchcock thriller. "It never occurred to her to sweep on to the set, and be introduced," continued Cummings . "She simply doesn't behave like an artiste".
Johnny

User avatar
Johnny
Honorary Member
Posts: 3641
Joined: 10 Oct 2007, 16:02
Location: Toronto, Canada

Re: Lucky Me

Unread post by Johnny »

Original New York Times Review
Bosley Crowther

Lucky Me -April 10-1954

"Somewhere along about the middle of the musical, "Lucky Me", which bounced off a Warner Brothers sound stage and into the Paramount yesterday, somebody hauls off and lathers the face of Robert Cummings with a custard pie. This is a fair indication of the type and desperation of this film. Launched on the optimistic notion that there is still someplace to go with a story about four stranded holders who bravely refuse to die, this project apparently collided with disillusion before it got to mid-stream , and at that point began to flounder. It was every man for himself from then on. Most successful in the subsequent endeavors to grab hold of pieces of the script and use them for momentary buoyancy is the leading lady, Doris Day. With the help and consideration of Director Jack Donahue , who tosses her pieces of driftwood , she bobs up persistently as the most elastic --and most lovely -- of the stranded song -and -dance team.
She is breezy, bright and lyric when the spirits of the others are most low. And it is she who has the inspiration to slap Mr. Cummings with the pie. Pressing Miss Day , however, is Phil Silvers, who is nobody's slouch at grabbing whatever opportunities for survival may be drifting around. As the top banana of "Parisian Pretties", the show that goes on the rocks in Miami, he shoves into the foreground of the picture whenever he can. And it must be said for Mr. Silvers he does alright when he is there, in spite of the water-logged conditions of the pieces of the script onto which he grabs.
In one final scene where he takes off a Texas millionaire , the fast talking holder from the Main Stem provides the funniest stuff in the show. As for Eddie Foy Jr. and Nancy Walker , the other members of the team, they are left with very little to grab onto , and their drsparation shows. Mr. Cummings is virtually foundered as the musical composer who finally leads the team to fame. How this little matter is accomplished is one of those mysterious things that are taken for granted in a movie --or rather, taken as a licence of the script. Certainly
the Sammy Fain music provided for "Lucky Me" is not the sort that will elevate the fortunes of anyone here involved. But the picture is colourful and frenzied , in CinemaScope with stereophonic sound. Perhaps that will draw attention from the general disarray of the whole show".
Johnny

User avatar
Johnny
Honorary Member
Posts: 3641
Joined: 10 Oct 2007, 16:02
Location: Toronto, Canada

Re: Lucky Me

Unread post by Johnny »

TCM Production Notes


"The role played by Robert Cummings was listed in some reviews as "Dick", although the character is called "Brad Carson" in the film. Gordon MacRae, who had teamed with Doris Day on several previous Warner Bros. productions was originally cast in that role, according to a March 1953 Los Angeles Examiner news item. A February 1953 Hollywood Reporter news item announced that William Jacobs would produce the film, pending his recovery from illness; however, Jacobs died on September 30, 1953. Although their appearance in the film has not been confirmed, Hollywood Reporter news items add Havis Davenport, Paul Haakon, Lari Thomas , Lucy McAleer and Molly McCart to the cast.
Although a November 1953 Hollywood Reporter news item announced that the film would be presented in 3D, the film was shot in wide-screen only. The filming of the pie throwing scene , for which twenty- four pies were baked , was described in a January 1954 Los Angeles Daily News article. Exteriors were filmed on location in Miami, according to December 1953 Hollywood Reporter news items. Lucky Me marked the feature -film debut of actress Angie Dickinson.

Notes
Released in United States on Video March 25-1992.

Released in the United States Spring , April 1954.
Johnny

User avatar
Johnny
Honorary Member
Posts: 3641
Joined: 10 Oct 2007, 16:02
Location: Toronto, Canada

Re: Lucky Me

Unread post by Johnny »

In David Kaufman's book on Doris, the following passage occurred just prior to the filming of Lucky Me:
"In retrospect, Day's prolonged delay in starting work on Lucky Me might have stemmed from more than just her health problems. Her physical symptoms may have reflected in part the sudden instability of her position at Warner Brothers. Day had signed a "release" from her original 1947 contract with MCP on July 27-1953, and was poised to sign a "new contract of employment", with the studio, committing her to two pictures a year at her old rate of $2,500.00per week -- as opposed to $150,000per picture deal that Melcher had been striving for and come to expect."

"But Melcher was still in the process of negotiating the creation of his own company, Arwin. His plan for his wife was to gain a share of the film profits as well. Iñ her column on October 19 -1953, Hedda Hopper reported: "Marty Melcher and Jack Warner have been in business huddles for some weeks . The result is a new production company headed by Marty on the Warner lot". Day's delaying work on Lucky Me was possibly a tactic of her husband 's. Hopper added that Melcher 's first picture under the new management would be Yankee Doodle Girl, written by his partner , Dick Dorso, and starring Day. Though the film was never made , the Melchers company Arwin Productions would materialize by the following spring . Part of the deal with Warners included an agreement- signed on Aug15-1953 - stipulating that Arwin would retain the publishing rights to any songs introduced in Day's pictures. "

"Despite reports to the contrary, a new contract between Day and Warner Brothers, so long under negotiations, was apparently never concluded. She made both Lucky Me and her next picture for the studio, Young at Heart, under special agreement. "
Johnny

User avatar
Johnny
Honorary Member
Posts: 3641
Joined: 10 Oct 2007, 16:02
Location: Toronto, Canada

Re: Lucky Me

Unread post by Johnny »

In Doris Day's book , Doris Day, Her Own Story she writes about filming Lucky Me:

" Warners was getting very insistent about the start of my next picture, Lucky Me; when Dr. von Hagen finally gave me the green light to go back to work. I read the script and was dismayed at how bad it was. Robert Cummings, Phil Silvers, Nancy Walker, and Eddie Foy Jr. were all talented, funny people , but I knew by now that no amount of talent can overcome an inferior script, especially if it is a comedy. What I didn't want to do , after the rough time I had had, was to get involved in a project for which I had no enthusiasm. I also knew that the only way not to do a film that had a poor script was to take a suspension.

Doris felt obligated to honour her contact, according to the teachings of her Christian Science principles.
Johnny

User avatar
Johnny
Honorary Member
Posts: 3641
Joined: 10 Oct 2007, 16:02
Location: Toronto, Canada

Re: Lucky Me

Unread post by Johnny »

In 1954 Los Angeles Times review, critic Philip K. Scheuer described Lucky Me as a desperate, ordinary film relying almost on Doris Day's star power, according to historical summaries. Scheuer panned thr thin plot , noting the Cinemascope format made ing8mate scenes feel lost while highlighting the wesk script, though he praised the efforts of co- stars Phil Silvers , and Nancy Walker."

"Location shooting for the film took place in Miami. Martha Hyer who had been cast on the straight of her performance in So Big later recalled, " Doris was not feeling well during the filming of Lucky Me but never showed it. She was always smiling and had that rare quality of making people feel good just by being near her"
Johnny

Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 11 guests