Calamity Jane
Re: Calamity Jane
Here is some surprising IMDb trivia on the movie Calamity Jane.
Day's performance inspired the look and voice of Jessie from the Toy Story franchise.
Doris Day recorded the song Secret Love in only one take.
Doris Day had to lower the sound of her natural , voice in order to sound more gruff to play the rough and ready Calamity.
Gene Nelson was originally announced for one of the male leads.
The set of Deadwood City's Golden Garter saloon was also used in another 1953 Warner picture: it appeared as the 14th Music Hall ( where extensive sequences featuring can-can dancers took place) in the 3 D Vincent Price/Phyllis Kirk hit House of Wax.
The western street exteriors seen here as Deadwood City had earlier been used as worn-torn Atlanta in Gone With the Wind, as well as appearing in countless Warner Brothers westerns.
The saloon interior was designed by Harper Goff, who also designed for Disneyland including the interior of the Golden Horseshoe Saloon, which explains why they look so similar.
Doris Day frequently cited this as being amongst her personal favorites of the 39 films she made during her 20 year film career.
Day's performance inspired the look and voice of Jessie from the Toy Story franchise.
Doris Day recorded the song Secret Love in only one take.
Doris Day had to lower the sound of her natural , voice in order to sound more gruff to play the rough and ready Calamity.
Gene Nelson was originally announced for one of the male leads.
The set of Deadwood City's Golden Garter saloon was also used in another 1953 Warner picture: it appeared as the 14th Music Hall ( where extensive sequences featuring can-can dancers took place) in the 3 D Vincent Price/Phyllis Kirk hit House of Wax.
The western street exteriors seen here as Deadwood City had earlier been used as worn-torn Atlanta in Gone With the Wind, as well as appearing in countless Warner Brothers westerns.
The saloon interior was designed by Harper Goff, who also designed for Disneyland including the interior of the Golden Horseshoe Saloon, which explains why they look so similar.
Doris Day frequently cited this as being amongst her personal favorites of the 39 films she made during her 20 year film career.
Johnny
Re: Calamity Jane
Original New York Times Review of:
Calamity Jane by Bosley Crowther
November 5-1953
"The wish of Warner Brothers to cast their spirited and sparkling Doris Day in the image of Betty Hutton is fairly clear in "Calamity Jane", a shrill and preposterous musical Western that horses into the Paramount yesterday. Not only they plunked their lady in a gun-slinging tomboy role that more than a little resembles that of Miss Hutton in "Annie Get Your Gun", but they pointed up the resemblance by employing the same Howard Keel who played hard-to-get Miss Hutton to do the same towards Miss Day in this film. The effort does not lack compensations. James O'Hanlon has written a script that is utterly cheerful and abandoned in tangling a quite unlikely tale. His Calamity Jane is a frontier female whose indifference to the graces of her sex is both rediculous and repulsive -- until another female comes along. Then Calamity enters competition with this lady for an Army Lieutenant's love, and all sorts of things come over her, including dresses and romantic songs. The chance is considerably for the better. And the fact that she switched her love to Wild Bill Hickok, while not quite historical, is a bit for the better too. Naturally, Mr. Hickok is played by Mr. Keel. Silly story? Beyond any question. Silly too, are some of the songs that Sammy Gain and Paul Francis Webster have enacted out of the air of music-writers row. "I'ts Harry I'm Planning to marry" and "Keep it under Your Hat" are bubbling with routine combinations of musical phrases and and words. Genius is not much more apparent in such jingles as "My Secret Love" and "The Black Hills of Dakota". But they all serve to spread bright melody here and there in the entertainment. No further comment comment on the songs. As for Miss Day's performance , it is tempestuous to the point of becoming a bit frightening -- a bit terrifying-- at times. The scenery is fat and highly flavoured. In Techniclour , it looks good enough to eat. But the voracity with which Miss Day has at it, and wolfs it down is unnerving to see. David Butler , who directed, has wound her up tight and let her go. She does everything but hit the ceiling in lashing out all over the screen. This is not all together entrancing. In the interest of a happy comic mood , Miss Day could afford to be less violent , occasionally a little more relaxed. Beside her, Allyn Mc Lerie , who had a frightened look anyhow, appears to be rendered immobile for all the snatches of dancing she does. And Mr. Keel , while directed to be casual
, loses stature and momentum in the film just because of the overpowering violence and stridence of Miss Day. Everything gets a little better after she takes on the airs of a woman and settles down. Tomboyishness is not the lady's forte. That's the score on " Calamity Jane". On the stage at the Paramount are the Ames Brothers Clifford Guest, Prior Brothers, and Pupi Campo and his band."
I would love comments from DD Forum members on Bosley Crowther's review on Calamity Jane. Associating the word violence with Doris' character in Calamity Jane seems to be a true distortion and misplaced.
Crowther's comments on tomboyishness not being Doris' forte is confusing since we see Doris in On Moonlight Bay and By the Light of the Silvery Moon being described as a tomboy. In an opening scene she is under a car doing repairs and also in another scene Gordon MacRae mistakes her for a boy.
Calamity Jane by Bosley Crowther
November 5-1953
"The wish of Warner Brothers to cast their spirited and sparkling Doris Day in the image of Betty Hutton is fairly clear in "Calamity Jane", a shrill and preposterous musical Western that horses into the Paramount yesterday. Not only they plunked their lady in a gun-slinging tomboy role that more than a little resembles that of Miss Hutton in "Annie Get Your Gun", but they pointed up the resemblance by employing the same Howard Keel who played hard-to-get Miss Hutton to do the same towards Miss Day in this film. The effort does not lack compensations. James O'Hanlon has written a script that is utterly cheerful and abandoned in tangling a quite unlikely tale. His Calamity Jane is a frontier female whose indifference to the graces of her sex is both rediculous and repulsive -- until another female comes along. Then Calamity enters competition with this lady for an Army Lieutenant's love, and all sorts of things come over her, including dresses and romantic songs. The chance is considerably for the better. And the fact that she switched her love to Wild Bill Hickok, while not quite historical, is a bit for the better too. Naturally, Mr. Hickok is played by Mr. Keel. Silly story? Beyond any question. Silly too, are some of the songs that Sammy Gain and Paul Francis Webster have enacted out of the air of music-writers row. "I'ts Harry I'm Planning to marry" and "Keep it under Your Hat" are bubbling with routine combinations of musical phrases and and words. Genius is not much more apparent in such jingles as "My Secret Love" and "The Black Hills of Dakota". But they all serve to spread bright melody here and there in the entertainment. No further comment comment on the songs. As for Miss Day's performance , it is tempestuous to the point of becoming a bit frightening -- a bit terrifying-- at times. The scenery is fat and highly flavoured. In Techniclour , it looks good enough to eat. But the voracity with which Miss Day has at it, and wolfs it down is unnerving to see. David Butler , who directed, has wound her up tight and let her go. She does everything but hit the ceiling in lashing out all over the screen. This is not all together entrancing. In the interest of a happy comic mood , Miss Day could afford to be less violent , occasionally a little more relaxed. Beside her, Allyn Mc Lerie , who had a frightened look anyhow, appears to be rendered immobile for all the snatches of dancing she does. And Mr. Keel , while directed to be casual
, loses stature and momentum in the film just because of the overpowering violence and stridence of Miss Day. Everything gets a little better after she takes on the airs of a woman and settles down. Tomboyishness is not the lady's forte. That's the score on " Calamity Jane". On the stage at the Paramount are the Ames Brothers Clifford Guest, Prior Brothers, and Pupi Campo and his band."
I would love comments from DD Forum members on Bosley Crowther's review on Calamity Jane. Associating the word violence with Doris' character in Calamity Jane seems to be a true distortion and misplaced.
Crowther's comments on tomboyishness not being Doris' forte is confusing since we see Doris in On Moonlight Bay and By the Light of the Silvery Moon being described as a tomboy. In an opening scene she is under a car doing repairs and also in another scene Gordon MacRae mistakes her for a boy.
Johnny
- Peter Flapper
- Honorary Member
- Posts: 6660
- Joined: 05 Mar 2005, 04:01
- Location: The Netherlands
- Contact:
Re: Calamity Jane
Hello Johnny,
Giving this a shot... And yes my English isn't the best...
A great find this review. It's so opposite all the other reviews and even Doris feelings. Doris always said: "Calam is the real me." I thought about this review from Bosley Crowther for a while. And if I read it correctly, he says all woman should be ladies. And behave that way. The comparison between Annie Get Your Gun and Calamity Jane has been made before. Annie is a musical from 1946 by Irving Berlin and Calamity Jane is from a later date. In one of her early interviews 1949? Doris already mentions Calamity Jane, but she had to wait till 1953 to make it. It is possible that James O'Hanlon (scenario, has based his story on Annie Get Your Gun and Calamity Jane's original story) That Howard Keel plays in it, adds to the similarity. As you stated, Doris played "tomboys" before in the Moon films.
For me: Calamity Jane is a great film. Doris does an amazing job. The score by Sammy Fain and Paul Webster is amazing. And yes I even do like: 'tis Is Harry, I'm planning to marry (my brothers name)... And of course: Secret Love. WoW....
P
Giving this a shot... And yes my English isn't the best...
A great find this review. It's so opposite all the other reviews and even Doris feelings. Doris always said: "Calam is the real me." I thought about this review from Bosley Crowther for a while. And if I read it correctly, he says all woman should be ladies. And behave that way. The comparison between Annie Get Your Gun and Calamity Jane has been made before. Annie is a musical from 1946 by Irving Berlin and Calamity Jane is from a later date. In one of her early interviews 1949? Doris already mentions Calamity Jane, but she had to wait till 1953 to make it. It is possible that James O'Hanlon (scenario, has based his story on Annie Get Your Gun and Calamity Jane's original story) That Howard Keel plays in it, adds to the similarity. As you stated, Doris played "tomboys" before in the Moon films.
For me: Calamity Jane is a great film. Doris does an amazing job. The score by Sammy Fain and Paul Webster is amazing. And yes I even do like: 'tis Is Harry, I'm planning to marry (my brothers name)... And of course: Secret Love. WoW....
P
Re: Calamity Jane
Hi Peter,
Thanks for your insightful commentery on Calamity Jane. I really appreciate it.
Bosley Crowther is a legendary film critic and he has written many thoughtful , interesting reviews. However, you are right on point about his expectations about female characters in film. Sexism in 1953 seems to at the forefront.
Calamity Jane is such a joyful , comedic and uplifting musical. It holds up well all these years later. I believe the word "violence" which Bosley Crowther uses more than once in relationship to Doris' performance is totally out of place. I think there is a current of elitism which is often a trap film critics walk into.
I do appreciate Bosley Crowther's ability to present a unique view. I plan on researching more of his reviews on Doris' films which hopefully will be of value and interest to the DD Forum. Perhaps some insight will be gained in seeing a pattern on his views on Doris' performances.
Peter, your English is absolutely perfect. I don't
think I could speak or write in Dutch.
Happy Sunday.
Thanks for your insightful commentery on Calamity Jane. I really appreciate it.
Bosley Crowther is a legendary film critic and he has written many thoughtful , interesting reviews. However, you are right on point about his expectations about female characters in film. Sexism in 1953 seems to at the forefront.
Calamity Jane is such a joyful , comedic and uplifting musical. It holds up well all these years later. I believe the word "violence" which Bosley Crowther uses more than once in relationship to Doris' performance is totally out of place. I think there is a current of elitism which is often a trap film critics walk into.
I do appreciate Bosley Crowther's ability to present a unique view. I plan on researching more of his reviews on Doris' films which hopefully will be of value and interest to the DD Forum. Perhaps some insight will be gained in seeing a pattern on his views on Doris' performances.
Peter, your English is absolutely perfect. I don't
think I could speak or write in Dutch.
Happy Sunday.
Johnny
Re: Calamity Jane
In Tom Santopietro's book , Considering Doris Day there are some interesting , insightful and thoughtful passages on Doris' film Calamity Jane.
"Although Calamity Jane represents one of Day's most fondly remembered performances , it is all too much by half. Using a low, gravelly voice and overly exuberant gestures, Day, her body in perpetually bent forward , gives a performance like Ethel Merman on film: She is performing to the nonexistent second balcony.This is very strange, because Day is a singer par excellence who understood from her very first film, at least in terms of ballads, that less is more on film. Her understated gestures and Kern reading of lyrics made every ballad resonate with audiences , beginning with "It's Magic ", in Romance on the High Seas.Yet here she is, fourteen films later, eyes endlessly whirling, gesturing wildly , and spending most of her time yelling both at Wild Bill Hickok and the citizens of Deadwood City. As the New York Times Review of the film held , in what was admittedly a minority opinion ,"As for Miss Day's performance, it is tempestuous to the point of just becoming a bit frightening -- a bit terrifying -; at times...David Butler who directed , has wound her up tight and let her go. She does everything but hit the ceiling in lashing all over the screen."
She is butch in a very cartoon like manner, although as always, , the tomboyish Day never loses her essential femininity,( the fact that her manicured nails are always evident helps...)Her clothing and speech mannerisms may be masculine, but Day herself never is; it is one of the key reasons why audiences embraced her straightforward assertive personality. In the words of John Updike,"There's a kind of crisp androgynous something that is nice --she has backbone and spunk that I think give her a kind of stiffness in the mind."
[attachment=0]p1024_k_h9_al.jpg[/attac
"Although Calamity Jane represents one of Day's most fondly remembered performances , it is all too much by half. Using a low, gravelly voice and overly exuberant gestures, Day, her body in perpetually bent forward , gives a performance like Ethel Merman on film: She is performing to the nonexistent second balcony.This is very strange, because Day is a singer par excellence who understood from her very first film, at least in terms of ballads, that less is more on film. Her understated gestures and Kern reading of lyrics made every ballad resonate with audiences , beginning with "It's Magic ", in Romance on the High Seas.Yet here she is, fourteen films later, eyes endlessly whirling, gesturing wildly , and spending most of her time yelling both at Wild Bill Hickok and the citizens of Deadwood City. As the New York Times Review of the film held , in what was admittedly a minority opinion ,"As for Miss Day's performance, it is tempestuous to the point of just becoming a bit frightening -- a bit terrifying -; at times...David Butler who directed , has wound her up tight and let her go. She does everything but hit the ceiling in lashing all over the screen."
She is butch in a very cartoon like manner, although as always, , the tomboyish Day never loses her essential femininity,( the fact that her manicured nails are always evident helps...)Her clothing and speech mannerisms may be masculine, but Day herself never is; it is one of the key reasons why audiences embraced her straightforward assertive personality. In the words of John Updike,"There's a kind of crisp androgynous something that is nice --she has backbone and spunk that I think give her a kind of stiffness in the mind."
[attachment=0]p1024_k_h9_al.jpg[/attac
- Attachments
-
- Doris Day - Calamity Jane -1953
- p1024_k_h9_al.jpg (23.87 KiB) Viewed 26867 times
Johnny
- Peter Flapper
- Honorary Member
- Posts: 6660
- Joined: 05 Mar 2005, 04:01
- Location: The Netherlands
- Contact:
Re: Calamity Jane
Hi Johnny,
Thank you for your Calamity Jane update, and you've managed to get a photo on!!! I love Calamity Jane, the scenes and the film. Doris is very enjoyable to watch, but in a way sometimes over the top. Doris had good chemistry with Howard Keel and Allyn McLerie. The music is beautiful and I wished there were more duets in this film. I love the duets with Doris and Howard.
Great work!
Greetings,
Peter
Thank you for your Calamity Jane update, and you've managed to get a photo on!!! I love Calamity Jane, the scenes and the film. Doris is very enjoyable to watch, but in a way sometimes over the top. Doris had good chemistry with Howard Keel and Allyn McLerie. The music is beautiful and I wished there were more duets in this film. I love the duets with Doris and Howard.
Great work!
Greetings,
Peter
Re: Calamity Jane
Calamity Jane- Rotton Tomatoes Review - gives it a" 73% audience rating and an impressive 87% from critics. The film's whip crackin' form, catchy tunes, and the chemistry between Doris Day and Howard Keel contribute to its' ensduring appeal."
"In summary , "Calamity Jane " ,remains a beloved classic, blending music, adventure, and a touch of romance on the wild Frontier. So grab your cowboy hat, sing along to those holden tines, and ride into thr sunset with Calamity and Katie."
Whenever Calamity Jane is on television, I can't resist watching the entire joyous classic film. I have lost count of the number of times I have seen this film.
"In summary , "Calamity Jane " ,remains a beloved classic, blending music, adventure, and a touch of romance on the wild Frontier. So grab your cowboy hat, sing along to those holden tines, and ride into thr sunset with Calamity and Katie."
Whenever Calamity Jane is on television, I can't resist watching the entire joyous classic film. I have lost count of the number of times I have seen this film.
Johnny
Re: Calamity Jane
Re : Calamity Jane
There is a 2025 UK and Ireland Tour of Calamity Jane- The Whip Crakin' Musical Classic, starring Carrie Hope Fletcher.
" Gosh almighty! Grab a posse because the whip crackin' musical comedy classic Calamity is a rollin' on over the plains to a theater near you. Based on the much-loved Doris Day movie, this plumb fancy new production stars the milti- award-winning West end actor and singer Carrie Hope Fletcher ( Cinderella, Les Miserables ) and begins its' UK and Ireland tour at the Aylesbury Waterside Theater in January 2025."
"Meet the fearless , gun slingin' Calamity Jane- biggest mouth in Dxkota territory and always up gor a fight. "
It is impressive that 72 years later, the influence of Doris Day's 1953 film Calamity Jane is still relevant. The film's legacy of joy can still be felt. It is a timeless classic.
There is a 2025 UK and Ireland Tour of Calamity Jane- The Whip Crakin' Musical Classic, starring Carrie Hope Fletcher.
" Gosh almighty! Grab a posse because the whip crackin' musical comedy classic Calamity is a rollin' on over the plains to a theater near you. Based on the much-loved Doris Day movie, this plumb fancy new production stars the milti- award-winning West end actor and singer Carrie Hope Fletcher ( Cinderella, Les Miserables ) and begins its' UK and Ireland tour at the Aylesbury Waterside Theater in January 2025."
"Meet the fearless , gun slingin' Calamity Jane- biggest mouth in Dxkota territory and always up gor a fight. "
It is impressive that 72 years later, the influence of Doris Day's 1953 film Calamity Jane is still relevant. The film's legacy of joy can still be felt. It is a timeless classic.
Johnny
Re: Calamity Jane
Variety Weekly Magazine original film review on Calmaity Jane is incorrectly dated online as December 31-1952. Research indicated the review was written in Minneapolis St.Paul , on October 28-1953, a week prior to the release on November 4- 1953. The review states it was written by Variety Staff.
"Giving such Wild West characters as Calamity Jane and Wild Bill Hickock a workout in a tuned-in western doubtless had strong possibilities but Warners comes close to missing the stagecoach. Colorful settings and costumes add the entry some sparkle but the book is lacking in originality and thr players simply are uneasy."
Compensating factor is thd total of 11 songs ( music by Sammy Fain, lyrics by Paul Francis Webster l) which gives the production some entertainment wallop. ( Musical numbers staged and directed by Jack Donahue.)
Doris Day works very, very hard at being Calamity and is hardly realistic at all. She'd register fine as a country girl in calico or a cutie ftom a chorus line but strain shows through in her essaying of the hard and dynamic Calamity character. Howard Jeel handles the Bill Hickok assignment with listless amiability."
"While favorable, a number of Calamity songs suggest other scores of other years. As a matter of fact, the entire film seems a little familiar, having some ingredients in common with Annie Get Your Gun and Oklahoma! The dialog throughout is commonplace. "
1953: Best Song ( Secret Love)
Comments:
I find it puzzling that the review states that in Calamity Jane, a musical comedy, Doris is criticized for her character not being realistic.
The reserved review appears rather elitist and condescending.
"Giving such Wild West characters as Calamity Jane and Wild Bill Hickock a workout in a tuned-in western doubtless had strong possibilities but Warners comes close to missing the stagecoach. Colorful settings and costumes add the entry some sparkle but the book is lacking in originality and thr players simply are uneasy."
Compensating factor is thd total of 11 songs ( music by Sammy Fain, lyrics by Paul Francis Webster l) which gives the production some entertainment wallop. ( Musical numbers staged and directed by Jack Donahue.)
Doris Day works very, very hard at being Calamity and is hardly realistic at all. She'd register fine as a country girl in calico or a cutie ftom a chorus line but strain shows through in her essaying of the hard and dynamic Calamity character. Howard Jeel handles the Bill Hickok assignment with listless amiability."
"While favorable, a number of Calamity songs suggest other scores of other years. As a matter of fact, the entire film seems a little familiar, having some ingredients in common with Annie Get Your Gun and Oklahoma! The dialog throughout is commonplace. "
1953: Best Song ( Secret Love)
Comments:
I find it puzzling that the review states that in Calamity Jane, a musical comedy, Doris is criticized for her character not being realistic.
The reserved review appears rather elitist and condescending.
Johnny
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 9 guests

